It might be a bit late for me to put my 2 cents in, but here goes anyhow.
The criticism of VV2 seems to have generated a lot of heated debate. People do have a right not to like things about it. However, like many of the arguments, it seems like this one was more about how opinions were presented than the opinions themselves.
We are all villagers on Isola ourselves, and we do have to learn to get along!
Check out the VV1 boards for all the things-I-don't-like type threads...
As individuals, we have different likes and dislikes, different expectations from the game. While LDW could not accomodate ALL of the suggestions we made in the VV1 forms, they did an excellent job of putting together another saga in the Isola adventure for us.
Instead of focusing on the negatives, start thinking about what you would like to see from VV3 (after they finsih PT windows for me, of course

)