I have done all the other puzzles and thought that I completed the fish one too....however, it isn't showing as completed. Am I missing something? Are they just supposed to learn to fish? Or, could there be a glitch in my download?

You're probably fishing in the wrong place. If you need hints, you can check the Virtual Villagers Guide.

Thanks!! I had tried that so many times, but they kept going fishing in the other location! It worked and now I have ended the game.

Oh WOW! I wonder why they don't check out Virtual Villagers Guide if they want to know how to done the puzzles

How do I solve Puzzle 5? Pls help!

Check the Virtual Villagers Guide for hints or spoilers.