I have serious doubt about how much luck affects anything. For one thing, I am pretty sure I saw a kid with luck in love. For What!? And phobias, fears and likes seems to mean nothing as well. I catch bugs that my mayor is afraid of without any problems.

I did get the rabbits foot, and I try to have a mayor lucky in "finding" just in case.. But I have had some with other luck, and as far as I can tell there has been no difference..

Hmmm. I have an idea of how "Dislikes" work, but I'm still gathering data.

I did win the Lottery twice with a Mayor who was lucky in Lotto but this Leadership thing has me stumped. I also had a mayor who was lucky with collecting and I ended up finishing the mineral collection. So I do believe in it, but some of them I don't quite understand.

Lucky in Love has me stumped completely. Maybe it gives you a bestie sooner? Or a better bestie? I have had some stingy besties.

I keep in mind that the story line is not complete, and the Leadership or Love or Games attributes may make sense later. The Games luck is the one that has me stumped. Other than the illicit poker game that goes on in the 2nd story of Town Hall (which is another place the peeps hide out when you can't find them, I'm sure of it!), I don't know of any games in the, uh, game.

I assume things might change with updates as well. Let me know if your data shows anything. I had a lucky mayor in lotto, who also has a rabbits foot, and was told they'd have luck that day, on lottery day - still didn't win. LOL Go figure. But my orchards have made my mayors a decent income anyway.