Yeah, this is quite upsetting. I stuck it out and got all the collectibles, puzzles, heathens. I just need a few more trophies (lighting the fire, events, triplets, jenga).

I can't believe I played this far only to find out I can't complete it.

I'll be less inclined to play further games because of this. Reading walkthroughs and such first spoils gameplay, and playing through to not finish is just as bad. I'm going to try everything I can think of that i haven't tried yet, and then I'm done with it.