I think that there are many type of gamers: those that really want to work the puzzles out for themselves, those that want to "win" and those in between that need those "gentle hints".

For those who want to "win" (and it's really not the point to "win" LDW games), why not? They're not taking anything away from MY game play. Giving and getting step-by-step instructions will help these gamers feel good about themselves AND the game, AND LDW through this forum. Why withhold the info? It's all in the game guide, isn't it? (I didn't look myself, so I'm not 100% sure about this!)

For those who need some hints, why not? Many, if not most of the people who bought VV4 aren't hardcore VV/LDW fans. They like the games, they play them, they come here for help and that's it. And that's fine!!! Some people are new to LDW's games and need a LOT of help. I know I did when I played my first VV game! People need hints. Giving them hints doesn't detract from your game experience.

Then there are the "hard-core" LDW fans who wouldn't look at a hint if their life depended on it! I'm proud to say that I'm one of them, but I don't begrudge hints or even step-by-step answers to solving the puzzles. If it hadn't been for this forum and the generosity of the people helping me when I first started playing VV games, I wouldn't be here right now!

Let's let the players choose which type of gamer they want to be and help them out if they need it.

Happy VV4 gaming!