I already had a Crimson Comet, and trashed it by mistake. To make it again, I used the post by admin, the 7 magic fish guide. I spent a lot of time getting an orange fatfish, to mate with a Speckled Leaffish. Turns out, that makes a Crimson Leaffish. Not what the post says though. You can't make a post to correct it either. I think it's a typo. An orange fatfish and a speckled quicksilver would do the trick, or a speckled leaffish and an orange fruitfish. Might want to change, or update that. Have fun making fishies.