I don't think that is a bug. I found that most likes and dislikes didn't seem to affect the game. I had a dad dislike plants but picking up weeds. I had a mom dislike playing but she was loving that pinball machine.
Some likes and dislikes do have an effect though. You should try getting someone who likes running, but stay away from someone who dislikes jumping.
What kind of effect does it have if they dislike jumping?
In the VV games, I loved runners -- I think most, if not all, of us preferred them, right?

But in this game, I actually don't like the two runners I have as much as the "non-runners" as they almost seem as though they have ADD or something, lol!