The arguments in this thread are so convoluted and make so little sense, that the average person can't make heads or tails out of it.

Perhaps someone would care to explain, using very small words and very simple sentences, exactly how breeding villagers for looks is likely to affect a real person in real life.

Better yet, take each of the statements from my summary and debunk each one using quotes from the rest of this thread. Because I can sure find quotes to support each and every single one of them.