I am a bad guiding hand, I make them all fish even those that dislike fish when I had a bad event that took all the food.
Wow. How'd you manage that?! I thought if a villager had a dislike such as fish or water, and you tried to make them do that task they would just run off and say NO! I never knew you could (gasp) FORCE them (oh the shame) to do a task they had a dislike for.