Hi I have finnished every thing except to tray the key,
i gave the chief the poitant cactus, rose ,tigerlilly He ran around but didnot tray the key, what am I doing wronge

If you're trying to reach the key on the cliff, those are not the correct herbs to use. You can refer to the VV3 Guides for the right combination.

No I am trying to pick up the tray in the room with the ghosts are, thanks lesley

Please see this topic, especially Arthur's reply about how to get this puzzle to work.