Honestly, I have enjoyed all of LDW's games, partially because of its replayability, partially because of the excellent graphics, and partially because the story lines have hooked me. Enjoying all of them makes it harder for to choose my favorite.
That said, however, I must say, I have enjoyed Virtual Villagers 2: The Lost Children and Plant Tycoon the best because of the evolved graphics and because of the new elements (collectibles, totems, etc) in the game which make them more of a challenge than the first Virtual Villagers and Fish Tycoon.
I can only imagine what Virtual Villagers 3 will have in it that will (more than likely) make it my favorite LDW game.
