I'm not sure if anyones done this already but, here's how to make all of em!!^^(I'm bad at spelling)(this is only way. do not think that this is the only way!)i suggest u keep all extra fish, at least until you u get all the magic fish.ENJOY!

twin-fin spotanus + spined spotanus = green-fin spotanus.(first magic fish)

twin-fin fruitfish + orange spotanus = speckled leaffish.(second magic fish)

speckled leaffish(#2)+ orange fruitfish = crimson comet(third magic fish)

green-fin spotanus(#1)+ spined spotanus = speckled spotanus(not a magic fish, used to make one)

speckled spotanus + pink shark = oriental goldbulb(fourth magic fish)

orange fatfish + orange fruitfish = orange goldshark(not a magic fish, used to make one)

orange goldshark + orange fatfish = orange snooper(fifth magic fish)

orange goldshark + pink spotanus = wasp grouper(sixth magic fish)

speckled leaffish + silky shark = canary fire arrow(seventh and last magic fish)

hope it helped! if u have any comments or questions, please feel free to post/ask!(i might not answer for a while, so if its urgent, don't ask me!)(a lot of questions i wont be able answer!)

Thx 4 the answers, i only had 3 magic fish b4 lol, was wondering what the 7th fish was

I had a similar breakdown in my search to use as few fish as possible to get them all. I like yours too.

Marcey

im glad u like it! i imagine your grown ups, and it might be hard to believe a kid did this!
the 7th magic fish can sell for 250 i think, but i'm not sure. oh, if u have anything negative to say, DON'T SAY IT!

oh, sorry about it saying "this is the only way"!i ment to say "this is not the only way"lols

I would like to make those but the fish I need for it are all dead!

twin-fin spotanus + spined spotanus = green-fin spotanus.(first magic fish)

I have both these fish and when I cross them I don't get the magic fish. Do they have to be pure breeds in that they are descended only from those fish>

If you're playing the free online (Flash) version of the game, the first magic fish is not the same as in the downloaded full version of the game.

Hi = update - I just watched it hatch and its a speckled gold bulb! Its the mac version. Never had any probs before and I seem to be getting all sorts of odd combinations not in keeping with the guides!! I used to have one in the first batch I put it and it is in the trophy croom but I can't make another!!

Do you have Magic Fish #6 (Wasp Grouper) in that tank?