I found all of the fish except for #1
Would anybody grace me with the knowledge of how to create magic fish #1?
*~*Maddie*~*

You can get that one from hatching common eggs! That's the easiest way.

You're joking me! No cross breading? I could've sworn i've hatched common eggs

You might have to try a few batches, but you'll get it sooner or later!

I just managed to cross breed Magic Fish #1, by chance.
the proud Father: Orange Beta
and the Mother's: Twin-Fin Stickfish

The mother I got from common egg.
The father (Orange Beta) came by crossing:
a Hornet Spotanus, and
a Speckled Stickfish

The Hornet Spotanus once again is from egg.
The Speckled Stickfish is from the romance of
an Orange Stickfish and
a Twin-Fin Stickfish.

Both of them came from egg, so the Love Story ends here.

Nope, I just tried it. That makes magic fish #2 (the blue, speckled leafish aka Magic Fish of Sustanance)

That's correct. As for #1, it's still easier to hatch it from common eggs than it is to try to breed one.

Speckled,& Flaged Spotanus- will make it

Well,number one is a greenfin spototatus.To get it just match two purebred Spototatuses together and you've got yourself a magic fish!