I have both, though I much prefer Magic. My nature tribe it seems has a harder time learning. (That probably isn't true in the game but it seems like it!) And of course I picked magic b/c I love Harry Potter! HAHAHAHA

I like the different challenges of both -- perhaps with a tad more leaning towards magic that gives me tech points faster.

On a general note, wasn't lightning once "magic", as would an aircraft to a 16th century person? Maybe just things that work in a way we haven't yet figured out

I chose nature. Now that i've read your comments, i'll try magic.

Played both but prefer magic faction.

I chose magic first...shocking right...Magick chose magic
But now that I have finished my first tribe I have started another and am now trying the nature faction.

I chose nature because you don't know how hard it is to find food for them not to mention getting them t stay on the task for retrieving the food. I had 2 Villagers die of starvation because they didn't wanna get food

I had a tribe for each faction at first. After finishing all the puzzles, I decided to try a tribe that chose neither faction. It gave me a new challenge since I had to keep the population low and pretty much pause the game if I was going to be gone for more than an hour or so.

Now I'm finished with all the puzzles (except the sharks of course) and just have to build one more hut. My villagers don't really need the hut, but it makes me happy to see the village completed.

An added bonus of doing this was that my constant search for mushrooms has also helped with collectable gathering and this is the one village where I almost have a complete set of everything!

Oh! Bravo Lanchers! It was a difficult challenge, congratulations for succeeding it!

I have two tribes, one magic and one nature. I prefer magic, it's easier to get more tech points, and I like the yellow berry plant!

Well, yes, but since she quick quoted it automatically replied to you